Thank you @manifest for your feedback, and you have an interesting viewpoint. I’ll address your concerns one after the other.
If you look at all other models around the world, Lending Club and Prosper in North America, Funding Circle and Zopa in England and even Dianrong in China, insurance is not provided. Investors understand the product is an unsecured asset, so they deal with the risk. As our society is a unique one, it was imperative this was done. Primarily because our product is new and early adopters would be weary, and given the risk factors you mention, a credit enhancement like insurance will give investors on the platform an additional level of comfort.
Also, NPV is never used to price a loan. It is usually used to price capital expenditure and real estate. But that is by the way.
You are right about insurance costing a premium, and you’re also right about Nigeria’s fickle economy. We are partnered with an insurance company that understands our product and the volatility of the market. Henceforth, we have agreed on fixed premium rates offered to the borrowers that are much less than 3% of the loan amount. This is currently lower than insurance taken against automobiles and infrastructure (two out of the five biggest insurance categories in the country).
Also, the notion that there are “no regulations that track citizens credit profile” is untrue. Currently, according to CBN regulations, all Deposit-Money Banks(Commercial, micro-finance banks), Finance Houses and other financial institutions are by law mandated to report credit data to the credit bureaus that have been set up. This system, tied with BVN allows lenders to make enhanced decisions based on the new provision of, and access to data. This access ultimately has an effect on the borrower’s ability to access new loan facilities from other financial institutions.Also, there are elements of the law that criminalize default.In such cases, defaulters can serve prison time. The ultimate goal is to create a healthy credit culture and set up a strong credit infrastructure in Africa so it would eventually matter in buying a house, car, etc.
The key to sustainability for any business is customer retention and acquisition. In this vein, to develop FINT we have carried out extensive research and discovered that borrowers do not appreciate the bank’s floating interest rates during the loan term, and we have thus proceeded with fixed rates over the entire loan term. Our product is to be seen(at the beginning at least) as a fixed term asset.Especially because asset transference does not exist like other fixed term assets(t-bills or fixed deposit accounts) You might wonder why since the longest maturity is 24 months. However, the investor market here usually would classify that as a long term asset(mainly because of volatility issues)The idea is to secure a locked-in rate ab initio, that is both agreed upon by investor and borrower. This gives both the borrower and investor the ability to predict cash flows and provide a level of consistency.
However, the interest rates associated with borrower classes (AA-EB) before their loans are uploaded on the platform to be funded vary with economic conditions.This constitutes part of our interest rate pricing model. When the economy is doing well, interest rates for all borrower classes go down and when the economy is doing worse vice versa. It is our goal to continuously provide the best possible rates for our borrowers, and the most attractive returns for investors given the risks involved.
I hope this clarifies most of your concerns. Feel free to voice any others you may have…